Heart Shaped Cakes for Valentine’s Day

Heart-Shaped Valentine Cake.jpg

I had a single layered cake sitting in my refrigerator in the basement from my sisters birthday last week.  I had initially planned to make it a triple layered cake but we all agreed we didn’t need that extra layer. 

Remembering the cake was downstairs I tried to think of things to create with it.  I decided to make some heart shaped cakes that I could decorate various ways.  Since I had these heart-shaped cookie/cake cutters  I decided to attempt to use the heart-shaped cutter to make mini cakes for individual servings.

Heart-Shaped cakes

My first attempt was to ice the cake and add red sprinkles to the sides, then using the star tip ice the top of the cake.  This was my least favorite design.

Heart-Shaped Sprinkle Cake.jpg

My second attempt was to melt white chocolate chips. With my cake elevated on the top of a sprinkle container that I covered with plastic wrap, I poured the melted white chocolate over the cake.

White chocolate doesn’t melt to a runny liquid state like semi-sweet or dark chocolate.  So I added 3 pieces of Paramount Crystals to the already melted chocolate, and blended it in until melted.  If you’ve never used Paramount Crystals it helps to liquefy chocolate, making it easier to spread or pour.

After pouring the white chocolate over my cake I let it sit for about 5 minutes to firm up before removing it from on top of the container.  I loved the way this turned out.

Heart-Shaped White Chocolate Drizzled Cakes.jpg

My third attempt was to color my cream cheese frosting pink, then place it into an icing bag with a medium star tip.  I added swirls to the sides of the heart-shaped cake and outlined the top with concentric heart  shapes.  I then added that extra touch of pink and white confetti sprinkles.  This was my favorite and the easiest method of the three designs I tried.

There’s no need to go out and buy heart-shaped containers but simple heart-shaped cutters work perfect so long as they’re at least 2-3-inches high.

Make a sheet cake, in fact use a box cake mix if time is of the essence – Red Velvet would be appropriate or white cake.  After baking the cake, allow it to cool, then place in the refrigerator for 3 hours or preferably overnight to firm up.

  1. Flip the cake out onto a cutting board.
  2. Spray non-stick spray on the inside of your heart-shaped cutter.  This will allow for the cake to be easily removed after slicing into it.
  3. Starting at the edge of the cake press the heart-shaped cutter into the cake.
  4. Remove the cutter with cake inside, and set on a work surface.
  5. Gently press using your fingertips on the center of the cake until it releases from the cutter.
  6. With icing of choice add swirls to the sides of the cake, then concentric heart shapes on top. Add confetti sprinkles on top or sprinkles of choice, if desired.
  7. Refrigerate until ready to serve if needed.

Heart-Shaped Valentine Cake.jpg

Have fun with this project, and invite your children or grandchildren to help.  Everyone can create they’re very own Heart-Shaped Cake masterpiece for Valentine’s Day.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. Cute! A great way to use extra cake layers too. This is so much easier I think than making the individual cakes. My favorite was the pink one with sprinkles. 🙂

  2. What a creative idea for a heart shaped cake!

  3. This heart shaped cake looks beautiful, what a delicious idea 😀

    Choc Chip Uru

  4. What a lovely and beautiful sweet treat!

  5. What a perfect way to celebrate Valentine’s Day!

  6. Such a cute idea! I’ve added the cookie cutters and Paramount crystals to my wish list. You make it look so easy 🙂

  7. Beautiful way to spruce up a sheet cake for Valentine’s Day. So many lovely possibilities.

  8. You have done such a fabulous job with heart-shaped cutters! I manage to crumb everything in the process when I use cutters. All these are gorgeous!

    • The key is to refrigerate the cake at least 24 hours. That way when you cut into it there won’t be too many crumbs. You can crumb coat it but I found it worked best to pipe the icing on the sides of the cake in a pretty pattern filling in all the cake. That way it goes quick and no worries about the crumbs. Try it, I’m sure you’ll see it goes very quick that way.

  9. Fun stuff! Very creative and pretty — thanks.

  10. You are SO clever!! What a fun thing to do with a cake! I love all of the designs but if you put them all 3 in front of me, I’d probably grab the sprinkle cake. 🙂 Happy Valentines!

Leave a Comment »